Having personally lived in Esher, Surrey, Greenwich, Connecticut, and Rye, New York, I’ve had the unique opportunity to experience firsthand what it’s like to live in the affluent suburbs of both London and New York. While both offer a high standard of living, they differ greatly in culture, lifestyle, and even how wealth is displayed. From the way homes are designed to the role of schools in the community, here’s how these two prestigious worlds compare.
1. Homes: British Heritage vs. American Grandeur
One of the biggest differences is the style and scale of homes.
-
Esher & London Suburbs: In places like Esher, Cobham, and Virginia Water, wealth is often reflected in historic properties, gated estates, and classic Georgian or Victorian mansions. Land is scarce, so homes tend to be elegant but compact, with beautifully manicured gardens rather than sprawling lawns. There’s a deep respect for heritage, and even newly built homes often mimic period architecture.
-
Greenwich & Rye: In the U.S., wealth is often expressed in size and modern luxury. Homes in Greenwich or Rye are massive in comparison—open-plan layouts, home gyms, wine cellars, and entertainment spaces are standard. The presence of acre-sized lots, swimming pools, and even private docks (in waterfront areas) highlights how American wealth prioritizes space and amenities over historic charm.
🏡 Key Difference: In London’s suburbs, wealth is about heritage and understated elegance, while in New York, it’s about grandeur, space, and state-of-the-art features.
2. Cost of Living & Real Estate Prices
Both markets are among the most expensive in the world, but affordability and value for money vary.
-
London Suburbs: Prices in areas like Richmond, Cobham, and Esher remain astronomical due to London’s status as a global financial hub. A 5-bedroom home in Virginia Water can easily exceed £5 million ($6.3 million), with ultra-prime properties reaching even higher. However, land is limited, and despite high prices, homes tend to have less space compared to their American counterparts.
-
New York Suburbs: Suburban mansions in Greenwich, CT, or Rye, NY, can also hit the $5-10 million range (even going to the $20million plus), but buyers often get far more land and square footage. Property taxes, however, can be far higher in the U.S.—in parts of Westchester, annual property taxes alone can reach over $100,000 per year, a cost that is significantly lower in the U.K.
💰 Key Difference: London’s suburbs are priced high due to scarcity and prestige, while New York’s offer more space but come with higher ongoing costs like property taxes.
3. Schools: A Central Hub of Social Life in the U.S.
One of the biggest culture shocks I experienced after moving to the U.S. was how public schools function in wealthy towns compared to the U.K.
-
Esher & London Suburbs: In the U.K., families who can afford to live in places like Esher or Richmond often still choose private schools (think Eton, Harrow, or St Paul’s). While some state schools in the area are excellent, space is usually very limited (not guaranteed like most US school districts) and there isn’t the direct link between an area’s property taxes and school funding as in the U.S. As a result, private schools dominate, and therefore the parent social scene is far more fragmented as children in any one town will attend a huge variety of schools and boarding school is also far more popular.
-
Greenwich & Rye: In the U.S., public schools in wealthy areas are often better funded than many private schools due to the way school districts are financed through property taxes. Towns like Rye and Greenwich have extraordinary public schools with elite-level sports, modern facilities, and extensive extracurricular activities. Because of this, a far higher percentage of students attend the local public school, which becomes the center of community life.Events like the Rye Garnets vs. Harrison High School football game, a local rivalry game which draws over 5,000 spectators, are huge town-wide celebrations, unlike anything typically seen at a U.K. school sports match.
🏫 Key Difference: In the U.K., private schooling is the norm for wealthier families, while in the U.S., elite public schools in high-tax towns become the heart of the community.
4. Lifestyle & Social Scene: Reserved Elegance vs. Country Club Culture
The social scene in these wealthy suburbs also differs significantly, shaped by British and American cultural nuances.
London Suburbs: The wealthy suburbs of London tend to be more reserved and discreet. Private members’ clubs like Wentworth or the Hurlingham Club cater to an old-money crowd, and socializing often revolves around a day at the races, garden parties, and weekend escapes to the countryside. There’s a strong emphasis on legacy, tradition, and connections passed down through generations.
New York Suburbs: In affluent New York suburbs, the country club culture is king. Golf, tennis, and yacht clubs are central to social life, and networking often happens over cocktails at exclusive clubhouses. There’s a more dynamic, high-energy feel—many residents are in finance, tech, or media, and success is celebrated more openly. Philanthropy is also a big part of suburban life, with gala fundraisers and charity events playing a key role in social circles.
🥂 Key Difference: London’s wealthy suburbs lean toward old-world charm and discretion, while New York’s exude a more outgoing, club-driven social energy.
5. Commuting: Train Culture vs. Car Culture
For those working in London or New York, the daily commute is a major consideration when choosing where to live.
-
Esher & London Suburbs: Public transport is more widely used, even among the wealthy. Many Esher residents commute to London via South Western Railway, and even those with multiple cars often take the train to avoid city traffic. Some high-net-worth individuals maintain a London pied-à-terre to split time between the city and the countryside.
-
Greenwich & Rye: The U.S. is far more car-dependent. While commuter trains like Metro-North serve areas like Greenwich and Rye and are very widely used, many people also drive into Manhattan, especially if they work flexible hours. In ultra-wealthy communities like the Hamptons, private helicopters aren’t uncommon for quick trips to the city.
🚆 Key Difference: In London’s suburbs, public transport is widely used, whereas in New York’s suburbs, cars dominate, and commutes are often longer and more varied.
6. The Overall Feel: Tradition vs. Modern Prestige
At the heart of it, the difference between London and New York’s wealthy suburbs comes down to tradition vs. modern prestige.
-
Esher & London suburbs: The atmosphere is understated, traditional, and focused on legacy. The emphasis is on heritage homes, exclusive clubs, and a quieter, more reserved lifestyle.
-
Greenwich & Rye: These areas exude modern luxury, community spirit, and a more open display of wealth. There’s more of a focus on community events, top-tier public schools, and expansive estates with state-of-the-art amenities.
Both offer an enviable lifestyle, but the experience differs greatly depending on whether you prefer classic British elegance or high-energy American affluence.
7. Weather: Four Distinct Seasons vs. Mild and Grey
One of the biggest lifestyle adjustments when moving between these two places is the weather.
-
Esher & London Suburbs: The U.K. has a temperate maritime climate, which means milder winters and cooler summers, but also a lot more grey skies and drizzle. Snow is rare and short-lived, and summers rarely get uncomfortably hot. While this consistency has its perks, it can sometimes feel a bit monotonous—those hoping for true seasonal variety may find the U.K. a little underwhelming.
-
Greenwich & Rye: The northeastern U.S. has four distinct seasons, which makes for a dramatic contrast throughout the year. Winters are bitterly cold and often snowy, with months of frost and frequent nor’easters bringing heavy storms. But summers are hot and humid, with temperatures soaring into the high 80s and 90s (30-35°C). Autumn, however, is spectacular—there’s nothing quite like New England’s famous fall foliage.
🌦️ Key Difference: In the U.K., the weather is milder and more consistent year-round, whereas in the northeastern U.S., you get the full force of all four seasons, from blizzards to scorching heatwaves.
Final Thoughts: Which Suburban Lifestyle is for You?
Which lifestyle suits you best—heritage-rich London suburbs or the expansive, high-energy suburbs of New York? Let me know!